Skip to content

Ongoing supplies

Make the spear timing make sense

Steam PC · Evidence checked November 15, 2026 · Updates 1.1.4/1.1.5 rechecked; November 3 patch and earlier reply observations retain their dates

The short answer

Watch the minigame: release the held button when the moving arrow is vertically lined up with the green target. The developer says a successful timing input makes the character hit the animal automatically; aiming at the animal itself is not the timing check.

The November 3 patch makes the hunting reticle follow difficulty, with a larger reticle on Easy, and documents a Hard-mode deer one-spear fix. Update 1.1.4 (November 14) unlocks the spear from the start of the game, and update 1.1.5 (November 15) says that in Casual mode spear aiming follows the targeted animal. It does not establish that the separately reported distance problem is resolved. Keep correct timing, difficulty and a reproducible long-distance miss separate.

On this page

Put your attention on the two minigame markers

  1. Begin a spear throw using the interaction shown by your installed game’s tutorial. Keep the indicated button held while the minigame runs; no universal keyboard/controller binding is assumed here.
  2. Watch the moving arrow and green target, rather than following the animal’s movement.
  3. Release when the arrow is directly above or below the target in the same vertical line. A diagonal near miss is not that alignment.
  4. Observe whether the throw connects. Keep timing errors separate from the distance problem below.

Check the November 3 difficulty changes

The official November 3 patch says hunting reticle size follows the chosen difficulty; Easy has a larger target. If a timing window feels different from an older guide or another player's session, compare the selected difficulty before treating that difference as random spread.

The same notes fix deer not dying from one spear on Hard. That specific correction is not a verified fix for every animal, distance or build. The notes do not give a maximum range or say the separate long-distance report below was resolved. Compare the difficulty choices if the minigame is the obstacle.

A miss and a distance problem need different checks

The original player asked whether randomness caused misses. Developer reply #1 says there is no random throw spread in this mechanic. Later, another player reported a failure at greater distance despite correct alignment; developer #3 said they would investigate it.

If you are missing while learning the timing, focus on those two markers first. If you can reproduce a miss despite alignment, compare a closer attempt and retain the animal, approximate distance and installed build for a useful bug report. No verified maximum range is available here.

The developer also describes an intended one-hit result for animals such as deer in that reply. Because the thread contains a contrary player report and an investigation, this guide does not promise a one-hit result in every situation.

If the timing minigame is the obstacle

Player #4 recommends iron traps as an alternative for deer and wild boar; another player also mentions progressing to traps. This is attributed community advice, not our own test.

In the later developer reply, upgrading the Workbench unlocks the iron trap. The upgrade uses wood from trees in the Swamp and steel plates made at the Forge. Check the upgrade’s actual displayed quantities and requirements before gathering; the reply does not provide a full trap recipe, placement procedure or yield. Do not confuse a hunting trap with the workbench fish-trap alternative.

Your result check

You can identify the two aligned markers and release deliberately, then see the throw connect. If repeated aligned attempts still fail, use the distance/build branch rather than assuming random spread or spending every spear on the same test.

Sources & version

Steam PC release. Throwing Spears feels weird, full OP and six replies: developer #1 timing/no-randomness explanation; player #2 and developer #3 distance issue, with Portuguese replies summarized in English; player #4 trap alternative and #5 practice report. That dated thread read is reused.

Evidence checked November 4, 2026: official November 3 patch, published16:28:42UTC, for difficulty-based hunting reticles and the Hard-deer correction. No personal playtest, exact range or verified trap recipe is claimed.

The full current thread, OP and 17 replies over two pages, was read November 4, completed at 22:13:06 UTC. Later developer reply #16 supplies the Workbench-upgrade path, Swamp wood and Forge steel plates for the trap unlock. The earlier six-reply read remains historical. The later high-FPS suspicion is not a confirmed cause or FPS-limit remedy.